Yesterday I was interviewed by ABC News WA, about the $5 billion donation of shares in Fortescue Metals Group by Andrew Forrest and his wife Nicola to their Minderoo Foundation – the single biggest charitable donation in Australian history.
Our discussions inevitably led to speculation about whether such a significant donation is motivated by personal gain.
It made me reflect on this cultural cringe that exists in Australia, leading to such scepticism and criticism of philanthropy particularly among Australia’s super-rich. It overshadows a more important conversation about how we can foster a stronger culture of giving, and acknowledging the sheer magnitude of good it can do – particularly when directed into a foundation or ancillary fund structure, where the growth of endowed capital in a tax-exempt environment has the potential to significantly amplify the impact that can be achieved with that capital over the longer term.
Yesterday’s public scrutiny of the Forrest’s donation ironically coincided with the release of the Australian Charities and Not for Profits Commission’s annual analysis of the charity sector, which revealed that Australia is well behind schedule in achieving targets to double giving by 2023.
As a nation, Australia gives at a lower rate than other OECD countries. Research by the Centre for Social Impact found in 2020-21, Australia gives at 0.81 percent of GDP, compared with 2.1 percent in the US, 0.96 percent in the UK and 1.84 percent in New Zealand.
Of course this difference can be partly attributed to differing structural factors and regulatory systems, but there is a genuine need to foster a stronger more supportive culture of giving in Australia, and ensuring our tall poppy syndrome doesn’t act as a deterrent to growing philanthropy that contributes to social change and benefits for all of society.
The $5 billion donation by Australia’s richest man, iron ore magnate Andrew Forrest, and his wife Nicola to their Minderoo Foundation can only be applauded as an admirable example of flipping personal riches into philanthropy.
Dr Forrest built Fortescue Metals Group into Australia’s third force in the iron ore export industry, which has been Australia’s primary source of wealth creation since the 1960s. Now the Forrests have given away one-fifth of their FMG holding.
Nicola and Andrew Forrest are setting an example for other wealthy Australians to follow. Kate Geraghty
The single biggest charitable donation in Australian history surpasses $3.3 billion that Ramsay Health Care founder Paul Ramsay left to his eponymous foundation on his death in 2014. The Minderoo Foundation is set to jump from second to first place on The Australian Financial Review Magazine’s Philanthropy 50 list of the nation’s top philanthropic funds.
Personal philanthropy helps build a vibrant civil society. Historically, this has been an area where Australia has lagged behind the much bigger culture of giving found among wealthy Americans. Established in 1964, the pioneering philanthropy of the Ian Potter Foundation was one of the notable Australian examples of combining business success with a social purpose.
Now, by devoting such a significant share of their wealth to philanthropic causes, the Forrests are setting an example for other wealthy Australians to follow and further deepening the contribution of business-led prosperity to tackling social challenges.
If you would like more information please call 1300 ELSTON or contact Susan here.
This material has been prepared for general information purposes only and not as specific advice to any particular person. Any advice contained in this material is General Advice and does not take into account any person’s individual investment objectives, financial situation or needs. Before making an investment decision based on this advice you should consider whether it is appropriate to your particular circumstances, alternatively seek professional advice. Where the General Advice relates to the acquisition or possible acquisition of a financial product, you should obtain a Product Disclosure Statement (“PDS”) relating to the product and consider the PDS before making any decision about whether to acquire the product. You will find further details of the service we provide and any cost to you within the Financial Services Guide. Any references to past investment performance are not an indication of future investment returns. Prepared by EP Financial Service Pty Ltd ABN 52 130 772 495 AFSL 325 252 (“Elston”). Although every effort has been made to verify the accuracy of the information contained in this material, Elston, its officers, representatives, employees and agents disclaim all liability (except for any liability which by law cannot be excluded), for any error, inaccuracy in, or omission from the information contained in this material or any loss or damage suffered by any person directly or indirectly through relying on this information.
Elston recently undertook national research with advisers and givers. This article provides an overview of the results and highlights the main factors that are inhibiting some advisers from discussing philanthropy with their clients. Read more
When many people think about estate planning, they’re initially focused on who they should leave their assets to. But often, through the estate planning process, they also find themselves thinking about the legacy they could be leaving. Read more
Our next Change Makers event will be on September 10 at Brisbane’s Gallery of Modern Art. We’ll be exploring how innovative QAGOMA programs are making a real and positive impact in the community. Read more
With the end of the financial year fast approaching, some of us are thinking about wrapping things up neatly in a bow and making sure we don’t get stuck with an unnecessarily large tax bill. But for others, the end of the financial year is a beginning. Read more
Treasurer Jim Chalmers is implementing Stage three tax cuts from 1 July 2024. When it comes to philanthropy and giving, this means that for donations made this year, a higher tax deduction will be possible, in comparison to next year. Read more
We often refer to Christmas as the season for giving. But in reality, EOFY is one of the most popular times for philanthropy. When reviewing your client’s affairs, it's worthwhile to discuss the merits of structured giving or supporting a charity. Read more
The Change Makers events shine a light on the transformative work being undertaken in communities right now. At our most recent forum, we focused on the people who are creating new ways for disability to be turned into ability. Read more
With the festive season fast approaching, giving back becomes front of mind for many of us. Those with children or younger family members also start to think about how to use this time of year to teach our loved ones that much joy comes from what you give and not what you receive. Read more
HUB24 announced the launch of a new whitepaper, ‘Directing the matrix: meeting the advice needs of high net worth clients’. Read now to get insights from Elston Head of Philanthropic Services Susan Chenoweth and many other experienced advisers. Read more
In recent years, charity, non-profit and philanthropic fiduciaries have started looking at how their investments can be better aligned with their missions. Is it possible? Read this article to find out more. Read more
Our Change Makers Forum at the University of Queensland brings together three pioneers in medical research who are striving to discover new solutions for some of the world's biggest health challenges. Read more
See what Head of Philanthropic Services Susan Chenoweth thinks about the $5 billion donation of shares in Fortescue Metals Group by Andrew Forrest and his wife Nicola to their Minderoo Foundation. Read more
Following on from the success of our inaugural philanthropy forum at Elston House in Brisbane, we gathered at the Art Gallery of NSW in March for another inspiring discussion. Our second forum was once again hosted by Elston’s Head of Philanthropic Services, Susan Chenoweth. Read more
Our second Change Makers Forum, which is also our first in Sydney, brings together three incredible women striving to achieve gender equality, invest in women, and improve opportunities for girls. Read more
As interest in philanthropy grows, more and more professional advisers are wanting to talk to their clients about structured giving. And starting a conversation about Philanthropy does not have to be difficult. Read this article for some tips. Read more
The discussion on our Change Makers Forum: Investing in Women night was fascinating and free flowing. Too dynamic to capture every exchange. But to give you a sense of the main points from the night, we’ve included some key excerpts in this article. Read more
Our first forum shone a light on the need for gender equality and the transformative power of investing in women. To learn more about the change of thinking that's inspiring more and more philanthropists, browse through our resources page. Read more
Published on HUB24
More Australians are looking to give with greater impact and are likely to turn to their trusted adviser for guidance. But are advisers equipped with the knowledge and tools to start the conversation? Read more
Published on Markets Group
When the giving gets tough, the tough... go to their professional advisors. The philanthropic space is complex, and clients need knowledgable professionals to help guide them through the giving process. Read more
This February we launched a public ancillary fund called the Elston Giving Foundation. The foundation has been developed to make it easier for you to structure your giving in a simpler and tax effective way. Read more
The speed and magnitude of recent events have shocked us all. The floods have hit our neighbours, our friends, our workmates, our clients. And it’s hard to know how long the road to recovery may be. Read more